'Ugh, What's Up With All These Feminists Being Funny?' Says Chronically Unfunny Woman


This is a serious post, you beer-swilling, har-harring feminists. An adult is concerned about you guys. Please, take a break from lying about your rapes for a second to listen to this urgent announcement: Feminists used to be all earnest and dour and serious, back in the 90’s when grunge and Katie Roiphe were relevant. Now, they’re sarcastic bitches who make people laugh at stuff. WHAT IS UP WITH THAT?

In her latest for Slate, Profesh Troll Roiphe notices that feminists seem a lot funnier and cooler than they used to be, although their rhetorical effectiveness is debatable. After quoting something I wrote, she notes,

The implicit attitude of this kind of writing is: “Can you believe these bozos are still acting like this?” The tacit assumption is that we all take for granted a certain set of shared beliefs, and we should mock those few retrograde Neanderthals who do not agree with us. The tone is less urgent and more queenly. It contains the idea that feminism is cool, and that it will mock you like a cool and impressive girl at the lunch table if you are in violation of its principles. The idea is to make fun of your enemies, not preach at them. (This is not, I should add, a wholly new thing. There are historical iterations of this type of feminism in the work of Rebecca West, Mary McCarthy, and Germaine Greer, among others.)

Queenly as fuck, you guys. Like Tina Fey and Amy Poehler and Caitlin Moran and pretty much every other hilarious lady being hilarious nowadays. What’s up with them?

Anyway, I’m sure Katie Roiphe is a nice person, and I can’t say too many bad things about her as a person because we live in the same neighborhood and I see her walking around sometimes. In fact, once while moseying past my favorite book store, I noticed a sandwich board outside proclaiming that Roiphe was doing a reading there that very night. Maybe she’s going to blow my mind with some retro-contrarianism!, I thought. Maybe she’ll try to make serious inferences about how feminism is awful because something something Honey Boo Boo!

I wandered in just in time to catch her reading a piece from her latest anthology, a piece she wrote several years after someone wrote something mean about her on the internet (she must have finally Googled herself), called “Gawker is a Big Immature Baby.

I miss the days of earnest Katie Roiphe.


Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Share Tweet Submit Pin