Homeschooled Girl Kicked Out of Prom Because of Leering Dads


In case you weren’t already convinced that most high school dress codes are sexist bullshit meant to police young women’s behavior along totally arbitrary guidelines, this story should do it for you: a 17-year-old girl was publicly chastised and kicked out of a homeschool prom in Virginia because several dads in attendance were unable to stop ogling her from a balcony overlooking the event.

In a blog post at — titled, aptly, “Fuck the Patriarchy” — Clare, the young woman in question, wrote about her experience. According to her, she attended the Richmond Homeschool Prom with her boyfriend; the event’s only dress code stipulation was that her dress be fingertip length or longer. With that in mind, she’d purchased a below-fingertip-length dress with her own money — so, by the criterion specifically stated on the event registration, Clare was not dressed inappropriately.

When she arrived at the event, she was told by an event chaperone that her dress was too short. She protested, stating that she had made sure it wasn’t, and the chaperone begrudgingly allowed her in. Once inside, she met up with her friends and writes that they were all “appalled” that she’d been stopped, “especially considering we’ve been attending this prom all four years of high school and usually wore much shorter dresses.” She also notes that “We were… a little grossed out by all the dads on the balcony above the dance floor, ogling and talking amongst themselves.”

It was then that the event chaperone, a woman, approached her again. Writes Clare:

She took me into a corner in the hall way, with another woman, (who I’m assuming was a parent/chaperone) and told me that some of the dads who were chaperoning had complained that my dancing was too provocative, and that I was going to cause the young men at the prom to think impure thoughts. At this point I said to her that I hadn’t been dancing at all! Much less seductively… Then she proceeded to reiterate that my dress was too short and I that I was going to have to leave. I again showed her and the lady with her that the dress met dress code standards, the only thing the dress code said was it had to be fingertip length, and they never had us sign any sort of agreement to abide by that rule in the first place, and second of all my dress was in compliance with the one rule.

Despite her protests, Clare was made to leave, along with five other friends she’d carpooled with. Which makes sense, you know, because the nebulous menace of “impure thoughts” is so obviously dangerous to young men that it justifies kicking six teenagers out of an event they’d paid for!

This whole thing is infuriating, particularly because it so well encapsulates the absurdity inherent in how our culture conceptualizes propriety. We’re taught to think that women’s bodies are by definition impure and that displaying them is automatically salacious and obscene. And we localize that “obscenity” in women’s behavior, which is patently ridiculous. In this situation, a bunch of fully-grown men were gawking at a teenager’s body, and she’s the one accused of being “inappropriate”? Seriously?

Furthermore, “impropriety” is always defined from a male perspective: the “below the fingertip” length stipulation was merely a stand-in for the real, tacit dress code, which is “Don’t wear anything that a dude might find ‘distracting,’ i.e., boner-inducing.” Implicit in this logic is the idea that women don’t have any ownership over their bodies or any control over how they’re read — in short, that if men deem something “provocative,” it’s automatically harlot-garb. It doesn’t matter if it’s an event-appropriate dress or leggings, which are what I like to wear when I’ve given up on the week: if some phantom man might find your clothing inappropriately sexual, it’s by definition inappropriately sexual.

On the bright side, the event’s Facebook page was shut down after an outpouring of criticism for its organizers and support for Clare. Turns out that being a big, sexist hypocrite is never a good look.

Image via Getty.

Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Share Tweet Submit Pin