Is Maryville, Missouri the Next Steubenville?


The worst and most frustrating story you’ll read about rape in America this week took place in Maryville, Missouri. It involves two young teenage girls who were raped by high school football players while drunk. One was left abandoned in freezing temperatures on her front lawn, passed out. Her rape was videotaped. And that’s just the beginning.

In an incredibly well-researched story in the Kansas City Star, Dugan Arnett outlines how 14-year-old cheerleader Daisy Coleman (whose name appears in the story with the permission and cooperation of her family), her unnamed 13-year-old friend and their families came find that their lives had been slowly demolished by one horrible night. In January 2012, 17-year-old Matthew Barnett (the grandson of Republican representative Rex Barnett) allegedly raped Coleman, as another unnamed boy, a friend of Barnett’s, did the same to Coleman’s friend. Barnett’s friend Jordan Zech taped the events. Daisy was left on her family’s porch, barely conscious. The evidence, according to the sheriff’s office, all supported the claims of the young women. But two months later the case was dropped; prosecutor Robert Rice said the rape kits, interviews and Zech’s admission that he deleted the video from that night were not enough to convict Barnett of sexual assault and endangering the welfare of a child. Nor was it enough to convict Zech of sexual exploitation of a child.

Despite the dismissal, Coleman’s mother and family continued to seek answers and push for justice. That meant that they were harassed, both in real life and on social media (the hashtag #jordanandmattarefree was started by Barnett and Zech’s friends to celebrate). Daisy was kicked off the cheerleading team “for her role in the night’s events,” Arnett writes. And yet at least one of the boys’ families have said that they want an apology for what their son has been through.

Law enforcement officials that were involved have strong opinions about the case. Sheriff Darren White says there’s “no doubt” a crime was committed but that Coleman needs to move on:

“We did our job,” he says. “We did it well. It’s unfortunate that they are unhappy.
“I guess they’re just going to have to get over it.”

A petition was started last year that asked Attorney General Chris Koster to investigate why the case was dropped, but his office said they “didn’t have the authority to review Rice’s decision.” Rice has said of the boys, “They were doing what they wanted to do, and there weren’t any consequences. And it’s reprehensible. But is it criminal? No.” He also told KCUR last year:

You make your decision based on what you know and based on what you can prove, and, you know, I sleep well at night knowing I did the right thing.

Is Maryville the new Steubenville? (It’s worth noting that the Maryville incident actually occurred earlier in 2012 than Steubenville.) The details of both cases all strikingly similar: Teen drinking. Football players in a small town. Alleged rape and sexual assault caught on video. Twitter and Facebook harassment. The Steubenville case drew mass attention in large part due to the efforts of the internet vigilantism of groups like Anonymous. The group has now gotten involved in Maryville taken over the #jordanandmattarefree hashtag for their own use:

We demand an immediate investigation into the handling by local authorities of Daisy’s case. Why was a suspect, who confessed to a crime, released with no charges? How was video and medical evidence not enough to put one of these football players inside a court room? What is the connection of these prosecutors, if any, to Rep. Rex Barnett? Most of all, We are wondering, how do the residents of Maryville sleep at night?
We have heard Daisy’s story far too often. We heard it from Steubenville, Halifax and Uttar Pradesh. In some cases, it was too late. Both Amanda Todd and Rehtaeh Parsons, girls not much older than Daisy, took their own lives after the adults, the police and the school system, failed to protect them. If Maryville won’t defend these young girls, if the police are too cowardly or corrupt to do their jobs, if justice system has abandoned them, then we will have to stand for them. Mayor Jim Fall, your hands are dirty. Maryville, expect us.

Does this kind of internet attack help put alleged rapists in jail? Does it bring justice to these young women? Did it help with Steubenville? As Katie J.M. Baker tirelessly reported last month, the rape’s impact on the town been complicated. It increased an awareness about sexual assault for community members, but at a cost — it painting an entire community as responsible for the actions of few.

But aren’t they all responsible? Aren’t we all responsible? Internet attacks paint cases such as these the way they are presented in court: it’s us-against-them, good versus evil. With online vigilante justice, the issues become black and white, sometimes at the cost of actual facts. On the flip side, they fight fire with fire: much of the pain Coleman, her family, her unnamed friend and her family experienced was due to cyber-bullying. It’s the internet version of Hammurabi’s Code, and it’s often how we crowdsource and define justice. It’s just odd to think that we’re at a place where social media campaigns are what push our judicial system to act.

The Coleman family moved after her mother was fired from her job. Daisy has tried to commit suicide twice. Most recently, their house mysteriously burned down and investigators still don’t know why.

Barnett and Zech are in college and playing football. According to KCUR, “The boy who sexually assaulted Daisy Coleman’s friend…made a plea bargain and spent several months in a juvenile facility.”

If Maryville has any parallels to Steubenville, it’s this: you might think we all would have learned something by now. Apparently not.

Images via Facebook/

Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Share Tweet Submit Pin