Rich, White Harvard Student Bravely Rallies Against Affirmative Action
LatestThe Harvard Crimson, one of Harvard’s student-run newspapers, recently published an opinion piece by student Sarah Siskind titled “Affirmative Dissatisfaction. Affirmative action does more harm than good.” OK, sure, I’m always up for a good debate. Let’s see what she has to say.
Race-based affirmative action attempts to target these groups: the discriminated against, the poor, and those with unique experiences and intellectual merits. However, affirmative action is fundamentally flawed because it uses race instead of targeting these groups themselves. Less academically qualified applicants should be treated as such, unless they come from poorer households and therefore do not have access to the same amount of resources as other applicants. However, this would be class-based affirmative action, not race-based.
Helping those with primarily low academic qualifications into primarily academic institutions makes as much sense as helping the visually impaired become pilots. How would you feel if you were assured before going into surgery that your surgeon was the beneficiary of affirmative action in medical school? I do not see why higher academic institutions should lower their standards for admission.
Normally I fight against the urge to pillory a teenager for writing dumb shit on the internet, but this girl, she will always have everything, and thinks it’s because she deserves it. She’s in dire need of a wake-up call because her little privileged libertarian bubble is painfully embarrassing, misguided, and straight-up delusional. Also, there’s part of me that’s convinced this is straight up parody — she’s like a straw man. She is the white chicks from White Chicks, right? Keenan, you in there? Because, GOOD ONE, QURRRRRL.
You know what I find most offensive? I’m for affirmative action, though I’ve heard interesting arguments about why it’s problematic and should be tapered off, and I accept that it’s not a perfect system, BY FAR. But this woman, this is just a joke to her. And it’s not even a good one. The worst part is that her flip, insincere opinions are about something that doesn’t affect her life in any meaningful way but matters a great deal to people who aren’t her. Leave that shit to PJ O’Rourke, this is just TIRING.
Does this woman even understand what it would mean to a family to send their kid to Harvard, as the first person in the family to go to college? Does she know, in that sense, it targets opportunity deficit, and not skin color? Does she know that the biggest indicator of a kid going to and graduating from college is if their parents have? Does she even begin to understand what it’s like to be in a family where you would be the first person to dream that big?