Here's How You Deal With Sexual Harassment at a Sci-fi Convention
LatestLast month, writer Genevieve Valentine was harassed at Readercon (a science fiction/fantasy convention) by a man named René Walling, a high-profile attendee who told her to stop saying things that “made [him] want to say “wrong” things” and then essentially stalked her throughout the conference in order to “apologize” even though she made it clear she didn’t want to talk to him.
Readercon has a zero tolerance sexual harassment policy, meaning that harassers are permanently banned from the convention. So when Readercon’s Board of Directors decided to only suspend Walling for two years after he delivered an apparently extremely moving explanation for his actions — therefore siding with an harasser who claimed he “didn’t get” what he did wrong over a justifiably upset victim of harassment — the community was outraged. Many people concluded that Walling got off easy because of his status and connections within the community. The board responded with this statement:
When we wrote our zero-tolerance policy in 2008 (in response to a previous incident), we were operating under the assumption that violators were either intent on their specific behaviors, clueless, or both.
During the course of our conversation with Rene it became immediately apparent that he realized what he had done and was sincerely regretful of his actions. It was that recognition and regret that influenced our decision, not his status in the community. If, as a community, we wish to educate others about harassment, we must also allow for the possibility of reform.
“Immediately apparent,” eh? Funnily enough, after the board announced their decision, multiple women came out to say that Walling had harassed them as well, both that weekend and in the past, making it clear that the incident was not a one-time misunderstanding. Here’s one comment from Kate Kligman:
I didn’t attend Readercon, but this morning Nick Mamatas told me the
guy who was bothering Genevieve Valentine was someone who had caused
problems for me too. Rene Walling is the chair of the Hugo Awards
Marketing Committee, and he was a french translator last year at Reno
for the 2011 base designer (I was a Hugo admin in 2010 and 2011 and
also served on the marketing committee).
I had worked under him online for a couple years, when he was the
chair of Anticipation, then out of the blue when he met me in person
he asked me to marry him. I didn’t even know we were dating. I told
him no, but since then, I’ve had issues with him following me at
events, and he didn’t ever really back off. For this and other
reasons, I stopped volunteering entirely last year so I could limit
contact. But it got worse after I resigned, he followed me around at
SF Contario 2, and I ended up leaving the event early.
I’m interested in the outcome, if any, because it’s a factor in me
attending Readercon next year. I didn’t go this year because I knew
he’d be there.
To their credit, the Readercon Convention Committee finally realized the board had made a grievous mistake and responded with an extremely thorough and incredibly classy public statement/apology in which they admitted they fucked up.