Allegedly Pro-Choice Susan Collins Confirms Yet Another Anti-Abortion Judge to Lifetime Seat

The Maine Senator provided the 50th vote to give a Trump-loving, abortion-hating law professor a job for life.

AbortionPolitics
Allegedly Pro-Choice Susan Collins Confirms Yet Another Anti-Abortion Judge to Lifetime Seat

Amid the chaos of the government shutdown, President Donald Trump prosecuting his enemies, and the secret police attacking protestors, Maine Senator Susan Collins voted to confirm an anti-abortion lawyer to become a judge on a powerful appeals court. Collins, who claims to be pro-choice, is facing abysmal polling numbers ahead of a tough re-election battle next year—though she hasn’t actually declared that she’s running.

On October 9, Collins provided the 50th vote to confirm Jennifer Mascott to the Third Circuit Court of Appeals, which hears disputes from courts in Delaware, New Jersey, and Pennsylvania. The Senate confirmed Mascott 50 to 47, with the only other purported pro-choice GOP Senator, Lisa Murkowski of Alaska, voting against her. The confirmation cemented a conservative majority on the 14-member court, with eight judges appointed by Republicans, including six nominated by Trump. (One of those six is Trump henchman Emil Bove.)

This seat on the Third Circuit is traditionally reserved for judges from Delaware, but Mascott lives in Maryland and is not licensed to practice law in Delaware, which is the site of many corporate and bankruptcy cases. Her only reported connection to the state is a beach house.

Mascott, a former law professor at Catholic University, is deeply conservative, having clerked for Supreme Court Justice Clarence Thomas and for then-appeals court judge Brett Kavanaugh. During Trump’s first term, she worked for the Justice Department and assisted the White House with the confirmation of Justice Amy Coney Barrett. She also joined Trump 2.0 earlier this year by taking a job in the White House Counsel’s office. Mascott has praised the Dobbs decision overturning Roe v. Wade, after saying that Roe belonged in “the dustbin of history.” In late 2021, while speaking at a Senate hearing, she also defended the court’s decision not to strike down the Texas bounty hunter abortion ban that nullified Roe.

Most recently, in 2024, she filed an amicus brief supporting anti-abortion doctors who sought to challenge the FDA approval of the abortion drug mifepristone. She also refused to say whether, under the Supreme Court’s 2024 decision on presidential immunity, Donald Trump could order the military to assassinate his political opponents.

Collins voted for this woman even though she is ostensibly seeking re-election in a state that Vice President Kamala Harris won by seven points. Previously, Collins voted to confirm two of the justices who overturned Roe: Neil Gorsuch in 2017 and, of course, Brett Kavanaugh in 2018, who was confirmed because she cast the deciding vote. While she voted against Amy Coney Barrett, her no vote came just days before Collins faced voters in 2020, and only after it was clear that Barrett would be confirmed regardless. When the court overturned Roe in 2022, Collins claimed she was duped by both Gorsuch and Kavanaugh, whom she thought would uphold the precedent.

Polling suggests that voters are very mad at Collins. A Morning Consult survey released in April found that 51% of Maine voters disapprove of Collins, compared to 42% who approve. The latest data, updated quarterly, shows that 56% of voters disapprove of her, with just 36% approving, meaning she is now 20 points underwater.

So let’s take a second to talk about the Maine Senate primary, shall we? Gov. Janet Mills (D) entered the race last week and, if elected, she’d be the oldest freshman Senator in history. That’s not great on its own, but Mills also praised Collins as recently as September 8. When asked if the Senator had done enough to push back against things like tariffs, Mills said: “She’s in a tough position. I appreciate everything she is doing.” Everything?? (That comment later got turned into a pro-Collins ad.)

Progressive Democratic primary candidate Graham Platner responded to questions about Mills’ statement by saying: “I do not appreciate everything that Susan Collins is doing.” And, yes, in the past few days—after Mills got into the race and the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee created a joint fundraising committee with the Mills campaign—a bunch of opposition research on Platner has dropped. Huh!

But after Mills announced that she’s running, she criticized Collins’ votes for Trump cabinet nominees, including Robert F. Kennedy Jr. and Linda McMahon. She also said the following:

“I’ve waited for some change in Washington. I’ve waited to see a difference in Susan Collins, and I haven’t seen it. Every day that goes by, I hear and see more distressing news and I don’t think I could live with myself if I didn’t do everything I could to take back this seat and to stand up to an administration in Washington that is hurting Maine people every day,” Mills said.

Again, Mills said she appreciated Collins just five weeks before these comments.

Collins needs to go, and perhaps Mainers need someone who isn’t a senior citizen.


Like what you just read? You’ve got great taste. Subscribe to Jezebel, and for $5 a month or $50 a year, you’ll get access to a bunch of subscriber benefits, including getting to read the next article (and all the ones after that) ad-free. Plus, you’ll be supporting independent journalism—which, can you even imagine not supporting independent journalism in times like these? Yikes.

 
Join the discussion...